SecludedGems Try it free

SecludedGems / Browse by tag

Lovecraftian hidden gems on Steam

Every game here is tagged Lovecraftian on Steam, sits between 1,000 and 5,000 reviews, is rated at least 80% positive, and carries a catch drawn from its own negative reviews. All 15 of them. How these pages are made.

Curious Expedition
Curious Expedition
91% positive from 4,486 reviews201631% finish itDeck Playable

Roguelike expedition simulation. Explore procedurally generated worlds, manage resources, and survive encounters for fame and treasure.

What players likedPlayers praise its engaging loop of exploration and discovery, reminiscent of a choose-your-own-adventure with strategic depth.
The catchRuns end to random events you could not have planned for or seen coming.

Games like Curious Expedition →

10 Minutes Till Dawn
10 Minutes Till Dawn
96% positive from 4,142 reviews2022

This is a free roguelite survival game where players create unique builds to fight endless monster hordes for 10 minutes. It offers quick, action-packed sessions with diverse character and upgrade choices.

The catchThe free version was disabled once the full game launched, so it no longer runs.

Games like 10 Minutes Till Dawn →

Cthulhu Saves the World
Cthulhu Saves the World
92% positive from 3,475 reviews2011Deck Verified

This is a parody RPG with a retro style. Players inflict insanity on enemies and aim to become a hero to destroy the world.

What players likedPlayers praise its funny story and witty characters, comparing it to classic Dragon Quest games with a unique battle counter.
The catchMaze like dungeons and constant random encounters turn the combat into a tedious slog.

Games like Cthulhu Saves the World →

Sunless Skies: Sovereign Edition
Sunless Skies: Sovereign Edition
84% positive from 3,452 reviews20191% finish itDeck Playable

This is a narrative-driven, roguelike exploration game where you manage a steam train in space. You'll make difficult choices, manage resources, and survive a hostile, Victorian-inspired universe.

What players likedPlayers praise its expansive lore and Lovecraftian atmosphere, comparing it to "Sunless Seas" and "Fallen London."
The catchMost of the playtime is slow, empty travel between ports with nothing happening.

Games like Sunless Skies: Sovereign Edition →

Sherlock Holmes The Awakened
Sherlock Holmes The Awakened
82% positive from 2,837 reviews20239% finish itDeck Playable

This is a Lovecraftian adventure game where players investigate mysteries as Sherlock Holmes. The core loop involves finding clues and fighting encroaching insanity.

What players likedPlayers praise its Lovecraftian horror and detective themes, feeling like a good remaster and continuation of the "Sherlock Holmes" franchise.
The catchVery linear with little gameplay depth or side content

Games like Sherlock Holmes The Awakened →

They Bleed Pixels
They Bleed Pixels
83% positive from 2,548 reviews20125% finish itDeck Verified

This is a challenging action platformer with a one-button combat system where stylish kills earn checkpoints. It features intense platforming and beat-em-up action with a Lovecraftian horror feel.

What players likedPlayers praise its brutal difficulty and combat-platforming, reminiscent of masocore games.
The catchNearly every action shares one button, so deaths come from fighting the controls.

Games like They Bleed Pixels →

Menace from the Deep
Menace from the Deep
85% positive from 2,456 reviews202432% finish itDeck Unsupported

A deck-building roguelike with card-based combat and a grim, story-driven exploration loop. Players collect cards and relics to upgrade heroes and overcome events.

What players likedPlayers praise its unique take on Slay the Spire-like deck-building, with engaging story, atmosphere, and character variety.
The catchRuns hinge on RNG and lopsided balance, with a long grind for meta upgrades.

Games like Menace from the Deep →

No one lives under the lighthouse Director's cut
No one lives under the lighthouse Director's cut
87% positive from 2,448 reviews20205% finish itDeck Verified

A first-person psychological horror exploration game. Players manage a lighthouse, uncover island secrets, and experience unsettling isolation.

What players likedPlayers praise its slow-burn, Lovecraftian horror, retro PSX-style graphics, and unique lighthouse mechanics.
The catchProgress stalls into aimless wandering because the game rarely signals what to do next.

Games like No one lives under the lighthouse Director's cut →

Forgive Me Father 2
Forgive Me Father 2
82% positive from 2,370 reviews202413% finish itDeck Verified

A Lovecraftian first-person shooter with dark comic visuals. Fight evolving enemies and manage madness to survive.

What players likedPlayers praise "Forgive Me Father 2" as a direct upgrade to the original, offering satisfying "Doom-like" boomer shooter gameplay with improved gunplay and art style.
The catchAmmo and healing run out too fast

Games like Forgive Me Father 2 →

The Chrono Jotter
The Chrono Jotter
94% positive from 2,240 reviews2021Deck Unsupported

A yuri psychological horror visual novel where players rewind time after deaths to solve murders and uncover secrets. The core loop involves deduction and altering events across multiple timelines.

What players likedNo comparisons to other games are mentioned in the provided reviews.
The catchBig chunks of the plot and the killing game rules are never properly explained.

Games like The Chrono Jotter →

Eldritch
Eldritch
88% positive from 2,213 reviews20139% finish itDeck Verified

First-person action roguelike with stealth, combat, and exploration. Players use mystical powers and unlock shortcuts in randomly generated levels.

What players likedPlayers praise its Lovecraftian atmosphere and tense exploration, reminiscent of roguelikes with unique mechanics.
The catchThin, repetitive content means the novelty wears off within an hour or two.

Games like Eldritch →

Sucker for Love: First Date
Sucker for Love: First Date
98% positive from 2,127 reviews2022Deck Playable

A visual novel dating sim with occult themes. Players make choices to date cute, eldritch girls and unlock endings.

What players likedPlayers praise this charming, spooky visual novel for its wonderful art, music, and memorable partners, blending horror with goofy fun.
The catchThe mouse chanting mechanic constantly fails for reading too fast and blocks progress.

Games like Sucker for Love: First Date →

The Last Door: Collector's Edition
The Last Door: Collector's Edition
95% positive from 1,852 reviews201411% finish itDeck Playable

This is a low-res point-and-click horror adventure game focused on investigation and puzzle-solving with a suspenseful, occult atmosphere. It follows a character uncovering dark secrets in Victorian England.

What players likedPlayers praise its unique Lovecraftian horror story, atmosphere, music, and sound design, making it a standout narrative point-and-click experience.
The catchPuzzle solutions turn obscure, pushing players into walkthroughs and trial and error.

Games like The Last Door: Collector's Edition →

Worshippers of Cthulhu
Worshippers of Cthulhu
81% positive from 1,516 reviews20253% finish itDeck Playable

This is a city-building strategy game where players lead a cult to awaken Cthulhu. Players manage followers, perform rituals, and build cities to achieve cosmic rebirth.

What players likedPlayers praise this city builder with light RTS elements for its fresh eldritch horror twist on the genre.
The catchProgress is gated behind timers, so much of the game is spent waiting on resources.

Games like Worshippers of Cthulhu →

eversion
eversion
91% positive from 1,341 reviews201024% finish itDeck Playable

Eversion is a retro-style platformer with dimension-shifting mechanics that alter levels. It offers a surprising plot and hand-drawn pixel art for a unique, unsettling experience.

What players likedPlayers praise its charming, unique descent into madness and parallel universe physics, influencing later games.
The catchHalf an hour of content for the price, with a free version already available.

Games like eversion →

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing