Games like Sucker for Love: First Date

A visual novel dating sim with occult themes. Players make choices to date cute, eldritch girls and unlock endings.

98% positive from 2,142 · 2022 · Steam Deck Playable · Lowest ever $3.99 (2025-09-29)

Anime Story RichRomanceHorrorLovecraftianCute

Six games like Sucker for Love: First Date

95% positive from 8,206 reviews2016Deck Playable

This is a visual novel where players make choices as a boy interacting with an emotional android. The game explores moral dilemmas and human connection in a near-future setting.

What players likedNo comparisons to other games are made, and there are no substantive recurring points of praise.

The catchThe main character is unlikeable and the supporting cast never rises above flat.

Both are tagged Romance, Cute and Story Rich.

Games like Lucy -The Eternity She Wished For- →

Muv-Luv

93% positive from 2,012 reviews201811% finish itDeck Verified

This is a visual novel with a genre shift from romantic comedy to sci-fi war drama. Its core loop involves experiencing a branching narrative with significant emotional impact.

What players likedPlayers praise its excellent character building, storytelling, and emotional depth, especially as a setup for its sequel.

The catchThe first half is a padded, cliched romcom slog before the real story starts.

Both are tagged Romance, Cute and Story Rich.

Games like Muv-Luv →

PARQUET

95% positive from 1,776 reviews202144% finish itDeck Playable

A Japanese romance visual novel about a synthesized being seeking his identity. It features a curious living-together experience and an unfolding mystery.

What players likedPlayers praise this wholesome visual novel as a charming, all-ages experience akin to a slice-of-life anime, focusing on self-discovery and mystery.

The catchThe story is short and simplistic, and it barely does anything with its setting.

Both are tagged Romance, Cute and Story Rich.

Games like PARQUET →

Sucker for Love: Date to Die For

95% positive from 1,194 reviews202446% finish itDeck Playable

This is a Lovecraftian visual novel with a dating sim element where players make choices to escape a cult. It features hand-drawn environments and a nostalgic anime art style.

What players likedPlayers praise its compelling story, beautiful art, and unique blend of cosmic horror and romance, transcending typical dating sims.

The catchBarely a dating sim: one love interest and an almost entirely linear story.

Both are tagged Lovecraftian, Anime and Horror.

Games like Sucker for Love: Date to Die For →

The Last Door: Collector's Edition

95% positive from 1,861 reviews201411% finish itDeck Playable

This is a low-res point-and-click horror adventure game focused on investigation and puzzle-solving with a suspenseful, occult atmosphere. It follows a character uncovering dark secrets in Victorian England.

What players likedPlayers praise its unique Lovecraftian horror story, atmosphere, music, and sound design, making it a standout narrative point-and-click experience.

The catchPuzzle solutions turn obscure, pushing players into walkthroughs and trial and error.

Both are tagged Lovecraftian, Story Rich and Horror.

Games like The Last Door: Collector's Edition →

Gray Dawn

84% positive from 1,182 reviews201816% finish itDeck Verified

Psychological horror adventure game. Features trance sequences with disturbing visions and demonic whispers.

The catchThe voice acting is consistently bad and undercuts the story it leans on.

Both are tagged Lovecraftian, Story Rich and Indie.

Games like Gray Dawn →

More like this: Story Rich Cute Anime Horror

More about Sucker for Love: First Date

What players liked

Players praise this charming, spooky visual novel for its wonderful art, music, and memorable partners, blending horror with goofy fun.

The catch

The mouse chanting mechanic constantly fails for reading too fast and blocks progress.

Reviews: 98% positive from 2,142
Released: 2022
Steam Deck: Steam Deck Playable
Price: Lowest ever $3.99 (2025-09-29)
Play: Single-player

It is here because it sits in the band this site looks at: well reviewed at 98% positive, but with 2,142 reviews, far fewer than the household names carry.

View Sucker for Love: First Date on Steam

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing

This page was built automatically from stored Steam data. How these pages are made.