SecludedGems / Browse by tag
Magic hidden gems on Steam
Every game here is tagged Magic on Steam, sits between 1,000 and 5,000 reviews, is rated at least 80% positive, and carries a catch drawn from its own negative reviews. All 16 of them. How these pages are made.
Third-person action-adventure in the American Deep South. Hazel becomes a Weaver, using magic to subdue folklore creatures called Haints and untangle her family's buried history.
What players likedPlayers praise the beautiful art style, captivating story, and amazing music, often comparing it to a Southern Gothic "Alice in Wonderland" or "Wolf Among Us."
The catchCombat is tedious and repetitive, with the same enemies in copy-paste arenas.
Games like South of Midnight →
A fantasy management simulation where you build and run a magic university using a card-based deck system. Manage resources, students, and teachers while facing external threats.
What players likedPlayers praise this addictive base-building and deck-building game, comparing it to Theme Hospital and colony games.
The catchLimited control and decisions that often feel inconsequential
Games like Spellcaster University →
Gedonia87% positive from 3,887 reviews20228% finish itDeck Playable
Open world RPG with deep character customization and faction quests. Explore, fight, craft, and build in a classic-inspired fantasy world.
What players likedPlayers praise Gedonia as a single-player MMO or Gothic 3-like experience with great loot, exploration, and player choice.
The catchJanky animations and combat that lacks weight
Games like Gedonia →
Fae Farm80% positive from 3,509 reviews202315% finish itDeck Verified
Cozy farming and life simulation game with magical elements. Players farm, craft, build relationships, and explore a charming world.
What players likedFae Farm is a cozy, comforting farm sim with unique twists, praised for its exploration, quests, and engaging storyline.
The catchProgress blocking bugs and broken achievements persist with no updates from devs.
Games like Fae Farm →
Co-op action-adventure game. Players cast spells, duel, and explore iconic locations.
What players likedPlayers praise its expanded hub world and extensive character roster, feeling like a bigger, more complete LEGO Harry Potter experience.
The catchStuttering and frame drops plague the PC version even on powerful hardware.
Games like LEGO® Harry Potter: Years 5-7 →
This is a turn-based fantasy strategy game where players build empires, research spells, and conquer enemies. It features deep city management and diverse victory conditions.
What players likedThere is no substantive information in the provided text to form a review.
The catchDecade old bugs still lock up the UI, crash the game and block completion.
Games like Warlock - Master of the Arcane →
Orb of Creation88% positive from 1,841 reviews20266% finish itDeck Playable
Orb of Creation is a non-idle incremental puzzle game focused on spellcasting and resource management. Players explore a magical sandbox to recreate a world at their own pace.
What players likedPlayers praise Orb of Creation as a deep, active incremental puzzle game akin to Factorio, offering constant engagement and meaningful choices.
The catchProgression becomes monotonous micromanagement and repetitive clicking
Games like Orb of Creation →
Conquest of Elysium 5 is a turn-based fantasy strategy game with deep faction variety and rogue-like elements. Players manage unique races with distinct mechanics to conquer a dynamic world.
What players likedPlayers praise its deep, replayable strategy and unique factions, comparing it to roguelikes, Civ 2, and auto battlers.
The catchThere is no tutorial and the clunky, unintuitive controls make learning it painful.
Games like Conquest of Elysium 5 →
Eternal Strands88% positive from 1,671 reviews202515% finish itDeck Verified
Eternal Strands is a third-person fantasy action RPG with open-zone exploration. It features elemental magic and physics-driven combat for strategic encounters.
What players likedPlayers praise "Eternal Strands" as a delightful mix of "Breath of the Wild," "Monster Hunter," "Shadow of the Colossus," and "Immortals Fenyx Rising," with engaging magic, climbing giant creatures, and strong characters
The catchColossus boss battles become tedious and annoying
Games like Eternal Strands →
PvP arena combat game with spell-based combat and strategic loadout choices. Players battle in rounds using magic and reflexes in dynamic environments.
The catchServers are empty and the game is long abandoned, leaving nobody left to play against.
Games like Spellsworn →
Action-adventure game with a deep spell-crafting system. Explore, solve puzzles, and fight enemies with unique, player-designed magic.
What players likedPlayers praise its Zelda-like puzzles and innovative spellcrafting, calling it one of the most enjoyable games in years.
The catchCombat drags because casting locks you in place while swarms of enemies pile on.
Games like Mages of Mystralia →
Vellum90% positive from 1,426 reviews202519% finish itDeck Playable
Vellum is a co-op literary roguelike where players use colored ink-based spells to battle enemies and save books. It features dynamic adventures with synergistic spell combinations and unique Tome mechanics.
What players likedPlayers praise Vellum as a unique roguelike with deep build variety, fun co-op, and Borderlands-like action, often compared to Inkbound.
The catchRuns get repetitive fast because movesets, enemies and build variety are limited.
Games like Vellum →
MageQuit94% positive from 1,423 reviews201912% finish itDeck Verified
MageQuit is a multiplayer arena brawler where players draft spells to battle. The core loop involves spellcasting and growing beards for victory.
What players likedPlayers praise this chaotic, varied spell-casting party game as a fun couch co-op experience.
The catchMouse and keyboard aiming feels broken, pushing players onto a controller instead.
Games like MageQuit →
A visual novel with fully voiced characters and HD visuals. It features a coming-of-age story with dramatic combat and animated elements.
What players likedPlayers praise its rich character-driven story, phenomenal art, animation, and soundtrack, often comparing it favorably to other Type-Moon VNs like Fate/Stay Night.
The catchThe story drags with flat pacing and characters who never develop across the runtime.
Games like WITCH ON THE HOLY NIGHT →
Cozy cooperative open-world RPG. Explore, discover secrets, and engage in action combat with class-based weapon leveling.
The catchQuests are mostly fetch tasks and combat is bare bones with no real abilities.
Games like Swords 'n Magic and Stuff →
This is a cozy fantasy adventure game where players deliver packages as a witch, focusing on exploration and broom flight. The core loop involves earning money through deliveries to upgrade brooms and reach the mountain's peak.
What players likedPlayers praise this cozy, relaxing game as a charming 3D exploration and delivery adventure reminiscent of Kiki's Delivery Service.
The catchIt crashes often and the sparse autosaves mean you lose big chunks of progress.
Games like Mika and The Witch's Mountain →
