SecludedGems / Browse by tag
Crafting hidden gems on Steam
Every game here is tagged Crafting on Steam, sits between 1,000 and 5,000 reviews, is rated at least 80% positive, and carries a catch drawn from its own negative reviews. All 38 of them. How these pages are made.
Wytchwood93% positive from 4,716 reviews202127% finish itDeck Verified
Crafting adventure game where you explore, gather, and brew spells to teach characters lessons in a gothic fairytale world.
What players likedPlayers praise Wytchwood as a charming, visually stunning, and story-rich "fetch quest" game akin to Skyrim's crafting, perfect for those who enjoy collecting and crafting.
The catchThe whole game is fetch quests and backtracking for ingredients, which turns tedious.
Games like Wytchwood →
Multiplayer survival game. Players live one hour lives, parenting and building civilization.
What players likedPlayers praise its unique life simulation and community-driven progression, akin to a collaborative village-building game.
The catchEvery action is mouse-click; you cannot move with WASD
Games like One Hour One Life →
Open-world mech farming adventure. Build, farm alien crops, and explore with friends in a retro-futuristic setting.
What players likedPlayers praise its polished, chill mech-farming experience, comparing it to No Man's Sky, Satisfactory, and Titanfall.
The catchThe automation shown in trailers unlocks only after dozens of hours of manual grinding.
Games like Lightyear Frontier →
Poly Bridge 295% positive from 4,519 reviews20201% finish itDeck Playable
A physics-based puzzle game where players build bridges. It features a core loop of designing, testing, and optimizing bridges for success.
What players likedPlayers praise Poly Bridge 2 as an excellent game for those who love designing bridges and enjoy technical, challenging puzzle games.
The catchLevels come down to frustrating trial and error, with little explanation of the physics.
Games like Poly Bridge 2 →
Factory Town91% positive from 4,451 reviews20212% finish itDeck Verified
Factory Town is a peaceful city-builder focused on automating complex production chains with mechanical transport. Players build and optimize logistics systems to supply their growing civilization.
What players likedPlayers praise its relaxing, simple, and cute factory-building gameplay, with a unique mix of belts and NPCs, making it a peak in its genre.
The catchThe UI is clunky and poorly explained, which makes building feel like a chore.
Games like Factory Town →
Survival simulation game. Explore islands, manage needs, craft, build, and fight to survive and thrive.
What players likedPlayers praise its in-depth crafting, exploration, and story, comparing it to Subnautica and Ark but with a more casual feel.
The catchNearly every interaction happens through menus instead of hands-on action.
Games like Survival: Fountain of Youth →
Immortal Life80% positive from 4,304 reviews20244% finish itDeck Playable
Life simulation RPG with cultivation and settlement building. Farm, craft, and explore to restore a sect and achieve immortality.
What players likedPlayers praise its pretty graphics, satisfying tasks, and unique cultivation, comparing it favorably to other farming/life-sim games.
The catchUpdates stopped with the game unfinished and promised romance content never added.
Games like Immortal Life →
Dig or Die90% positive from 4,271 reviews20186% finish itDeck Unsupported
This is a survival crafting game with physics-based building and resource management. Players explore, fight enemies, and build defenses against nightly attacks.
What players likedPlayers praise this Terraria-inspired game for its unique building physics and complex water mechanics.
The catchNightly enemy raids force a run back to base, cutting exploration into a tedious loop.
Games like Dig or Die →
FOUNDRY81% positive from 3,850 reviews20244% finish itDeck Playable
First-person voxel factory builder with creative freedom. Automate production, trade goods, and achieve galactic domination.
What players likedPlayers describe FOUNDRY as a 3D Factorio or Satisfactory with unique space station management and engaging optimization.
The catchControls and the belt system feel clunky and unintuitive
Games like FOUNDRY →
This is a JRPG with real-time combat and exploration. Players gather materials, craft items, and battle enemies in a vibrant fantasy world.
What players likedPlayers praise it as a refined sequel that improves upon the first game with better characters and story, while retaining familiar areas.
The catchOwners get no upgrade path to the DX rerelease and must buy the same game again.
Games like Atelier Ryza 2: Lost Legends & the Secret Fairy →
Kynseed83% positive from 3,731 reviews2022Deck Verified
A life simulation RPG where you build a legacy by running businesses, farming, and raising a family in a fantasy world. Features combat against monsters and relationship building with villagers.
What players likedPlayers praise Kynseed as a deeper, darker Stardew Valley/Fable-like life sim with rich content, art, and writing.
The catchGameplay devolves into heavy grinding for little story payoff
Games like Kynseed →
Aloft84% positive from 3,623 reviews20255% finish itDeck Playable
Cozy survival game. Build flying islands, explore, and cure a fungal threat.
What players likedAloft is a relaxing survival/crafting game, compared to Wind Waker, Sea of Thieves, and Valheim, praised for its unique flying islands, exploration, and building.
The catchPerformance is poor even on strong hardware, with constant stutter and frame drops.
Games like Aloft →
Relaxing open-world adventure game. Explore, craft, farm, and befriend creatures to clear a mysterious blight.
What players likedPlayers praise Yonder as a peaceful open-world adventure with building, exploration, and collecting, making it great for all ages.
The catchQuests give vague directions, so much of the time is spent wandering aimlessly.
Games like Yonder: The Cloud Catcher Chronicles →
Astrometica83% positive from 3,124 reviews202436% finish itDeck Unsupported
Astrometica is a space exploration and base-building survival game. Players explore the universe, gather resources, and build automated outposts.
What players likedPlayers praise Astrometrica as an absorbing Subnautica-like space exploration and building game with gorgeous vistas and engaging lore.
The catchDevelopment has stalled with no update in over a year, and it is still unfinished.
Games like Astrometica →
Outpath93% positive from 3,057 reviews202315% finish itDeck Playable
3D first-person crafting and automation game. Exploit, build, and explore at your own pace.
What players likedPlayers describe Outpath as a relaxing, satisfying blend of Minecraft and incremental games, praised for its progression, gathering, and automation.
The catchThe loop is endless clicking and progress slows to a grind after the first few hours.
Games like Outpath →
Feel The Snow87% positive from 3,052 reviews20195% finish itDeck Verified
This is a pixel art sandbox action-adventure game with RPG and survival elements. Players explore a randomly generated world, build, craft, and engage in dynamic combat with friends.
What players likedPlayers praise this charming and relaxing survival adventure for its surprising length, crafting, and co-op gameplay.
The catchControls are clunky and unintuitive, with no tutorial explaining the basic mechanics.
Games like Feel The Snow →
Card-based survival simulation where players explore, craft, and manage needs on a desert island. The core loop involves combining cards to interact with the environment and survive.
What players likedPlayers praise its rewarding progression and research, reminiscent of old-style games that encourage figuring things out.
The catchOversized cards show only a few items at once, so basic actions mean endless scrolling.
Games like Card Survival: Tropical Island →
This is a turn-based JRPG with a puzzle-based crafting system and weather manipulation for exploration. It features a story-driven adventure with a focus on character interactions.
What players likedPlayers praise the game's engaging boss battles, where strategic item use overcomes under-leveling, making it a potential series favorite.
The catchPerformance stutters badly on PC, with plugging in a controller as the common workaround.
Games like Atelier Sophie 2: The Alchemist of the Mysterious Dream →
Survival crafting game with base building and resource management. It's a free prologue to a story-driven survival game.
The catchConstant sleeping, eating and slow walking turn simple tasks into tedium.
Games like Mr. Prepper: Prologue →
Eden Crafters86% positive from 2,512 reviews20262% finish itDeck Unsupported
A singleplayer/co-op open-world survival crafting game focused on terraforming and automating planets. Players build factories to transform hostile environments into habitable worlds.
What players likedPlayers praise Eden Crafters as a simpler blend of Satisfactory and Planet Crafter, offering diverse planets and enjoyable automation.
The catchJank and missing polish make it feel like it never left early access.
Games like Eden Crafters →
Garden Paws90% positive from 2,493 reviews2018Deck Playable
This is a cozy life simulation game focused on farming, crafting, and town building. Players run a shop, explore islands, and complete quests to earn coins and expand their world.
What players likedPlayers praise its extensive crafting and building, comparing its shop mechanics to Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar, and its cozy, collectible exploration.
The catchIt is riddled with bugs, from invisible objects to items vanishing out of storage.
Games like Garden Paws →
Survival sandbox RPG with resource management, crafting, and exploration. Features procedural generation, base building, and combat in a magical world.
The catchProgress buries you in grinding and waiting on crafting timers for hours.
Games like Force of Nature 2: Ghost Keeper →
NavalArt90% positive from 2,321 reviews2018Deck Playable
NavalArt is a naval sandbox game focused on detailed warship design, construction, and physics-based combat. Players build custom ships and test them in battles across different eras.
What players likedLike From The Depths, players praise its ship-building freedom, realistic physics, and mod support.
The catchThe ship editor is unintuitive and tedious, swallowing hours to build even basic shapes.
Games like NavalArt →
A cooperative open-world pirate RPG focused on exploration and ship customization. Players craft, survive, and quest across a procedurally generated world.
What players likedPlayers praise "Salt 2" as a relaxed, cozy "Sea of Thieves" with deep exploration, crafting, and a mobile base.
The catchEvery island and quest blurs into the same shallow loot-and-sail loop within hours.
Games like Salt 2: Shores of Gold →
This is a co-op action-adventure game focused on exploring, gathering resources, and fighting enemies across diverse worlds. Players upgrade tools and gear to restore planets and overcome challenges.
What players likedIt's a casual, gather-and-build game like mobile titles, but praised for its ad-free, faster progression on PC.
The catchGrindy gathering with ever-increasing unlock costs
Games like My Little Universe →
Block Story™84% positive from 2,054 reviews2015Deck Playable
This is a 3D block building RPG with a core loop of exploration, questing, and crafting. It offers sandbox freedom with fantasy combat and creature riding.
What players likedPlayers praise Block Story as a charming RPG with dragons, offering a Minecraft-like experience with quests and character progression.
The catchMelee combat stops working early, with enemies out-reaching and out-damaging you.
Games like Block Story™ →
Amber Isle83% positive from 2,018 reviews20245% finish itDeck Playable
Shop management and social simulation game. Gather, craft, and sell items to diverse prehistoric islanders while customizing your shop and rebuilding the island.
What players likedPlayers praise Amber Isle as a cute, cozy, and addictive Animal Crossing-like game with engaging shop management and charming dinosaur characters.
The catchThe fixed camera cannot rotate, constantly zooms in on walls, and blocks your view.
Games like Amber Isle →
Arid87% positive from 1,952 reviews20214% finish itDeck Unsupported
Singleplayer open-world survival game focused on resource management and environmental hazards in a harsh desert. Players must manage dehydration, temperature, and weather events to survive.
The catchHunger, thirst and sleep meters drain so fast that little progress gets made.
Games like Arid →
Craft weapons for warriors to fight monsters in this action-RPG. Forge weapons, send warriors into battle, and upgrade gear.
What players likedPlayers compare it to "Papa Louie games, but with weapons and fighting monsters" and praise its nostalgic, creative, and addictive blend of strategy and progression.
The catchBarely anything changed from the free browser original beyond new character art.
Games like Jacksmith: Weapons and Warriors →
A turn-based JRPG about alchemy crafting and exploration. Players gather materials, synthesize items, and battle monsters to help Sophie achieve her dreams.
What players likedPlayers praise the character writing and enjoyable crafting system, despite a lack of strong story.
The catchProgression relies on heavy grinding with little payoff
Games like Atelier Sophie: The Alchemist of the Mysterious Book →
A fantasy horse breeding simulation game. Players manage a farm, breed magical horses, and care for them through training and races.
The catchRaces and quests play out off screen while you wait on real time timers.
Games like Secret of the Magic Crystals →
This is a turn-based roguelike RPG set in the Sword of the Stars universe. Players explore a procedurally generated dungeon, fighting monsters and improving their character to survive.
What players likedPlayers praise its compelling, varied, and strategic rogue-like gameplay with RPG and crafting elements, reminiscent of charming euro-jank titles.
The catchCrafting buries you in junk items and recipes you cannot work out without a wiki.
Games like Sword of the Stars: The Pit →
No Time97% positive from 1,538 reviews2019Deck Playable
A time-travel sandbox on Pine Island. Type any date between 1 and 3033 AD to change the open world around you, stalk your past selves, and stay clear of the Time Agents hunting for traces of you.
What players likedPlayers praise its fun, open-world gameplay, despite Roblox-esque graphics and jankiness, with potential for a perfect score.
The catchCrashes, collision glitches and unreliable autosaves repeatedly wipe out progress.
Games like No Time →
Dog Brew97% positive from 1,510 reviews202449% finish itDeck Playable
A cozy life simulation game where you brew unique drinks to pay off debts. Farm, fish, and experiment with recipes to satisfy quirky island residents.
What players likedPlayers praise the funny NPC dialogues, finding it an "aight" game despite not being everyone's style.
The catchThe brewing loop runs dry fast and turns into repetitive grinding with little content.
Games like Dog Brew →
Noble Fates83% positive from 1,476 reviews2021Deck Playable
This is a kingdom-building simulation game where players manage mortals' beliefs and ambitions. The core loop involves resource management, defense, and social interaction to grow a demigod's influence.
What players likedPlayers praise this fantasy medieval colony sim as a detailed 3D Rimworld-like with impressive projectile simulation and water physics.
The catchVillagers ignore assigned jobs, forcing constant micromanagement to get anything done.
Games like Noble Fates →
Farlands93% positive from 1,456 reviews2024Deck Verified
Farming and exploration simulation. Restore a planet and its solar system through resource gathering and community interaction.
What players likedPlayers praise Farlands as a charming space-farming game, often compared to Stardew Valley, with beautiful art, delightful music, and enjoyable gameplay.
The catchAlmost nothing is explained, from item descriptions to where you should go next.
Games like Farlands →
MewnBase93% positive from 1,440 reviews20232% finish itDeck Playable
MewnBase is a 2D survival crafting game where players build a base and manage resources on an alien planet. It features exploration, technology upgrades, and environmental hazards.
The catchIt runs out of content fast, leaving a shallow loop with almost no replay value.
Games like MewnBase →
Wayward86% positive from 1,363 reviews2016Deck Playable
A challenging wilderness survival roguelike with deep crafting and skill progression. Explore procedurally generated islands, manage resources, and interact with a simulated world.
What players likedPlayers say Wayward is like Don't Starve, praised for its surprising depth despite a simple surface.
The catchThe interface is obtuse, turning simple actions into repeated menu clicks.
Games like Wayward →
