SecludedGems / Browse by tag
Choose Your Own Adventure hidden gems on Steam
Every game here is tagged Choose Your Own Adventure on Steam, sits between 1,000 and 5,000 reviews, is rated at least 80% positive, and carries a catch drawn from its own negative reviews. All 31 of them. How these pages are made.
This is a short, psychological simulation horror game where players answer questions to uncover hidden truths about themselves. It features player-developer interaction and a focus on atmospheric introspection.
What players likedPlayers praise "The Test: Final Revelation" as a unique, once-in-a-lifetime experience that's incredibly worthwhile, especially given its low cost.
The catchThe final result is vague horoscope style advice that could apply to anyone.
Games like The Test: Final Revelation →
A narrative-driven visual novel with puzzle elements. Players navigate a survival game with racial tensions and a doppelganger mechanic.
What players likedPlayers praise its charming characters, deep story/lore, and unique otome experience, despite some translation issues.
The catchOn Mac, an error screen after finding the key blocks any further progress.
Games like Ten Trials of Babel: The Doppelganger Maze →
As Dusk Falls90% positive from 4,314 reviews202249% finish itDeck Unsupported
Interactive drama where player choices shape entangled family lives across decades. Experience a crime story with a motion comic art style and cooperative multiplayer.
What players likedPlayers praise its impactful choices and engaging story, comparing it to interactive narrative games like Detroit: Become Human and Telltale titles.
The catchThe story stops on an unresolved cliffhanger with no sequel to finish it.
Games like As Dusk Falls →
Interactive sitcom with branching narratives and dark humor. Features a socially realistic protagonist and a late 2000s aesthetic.
What players likedPlayers say it's a well-made, tighter continuation of the first game, praised for its humor and characterization.
The catchIt plays as a step down from the first game with fewer choices and endings.
Games like Class of 09: The Re-Up →
Out of Ore86% positive from 3,975 reviews2022Deck Unsupported
This is a mining and industrial simulation game focused on resource extraction, production, and logistics. Players build a company from scratch, managing operations and vehicles across large maps.
What players likedPlayers praise this mining simulator as "Minecraft for adults" with excellent dirt physics, offering endless fun, especially with friends.
The catchVehicle controls are clunky and unintuitive on keyboard, mouse and controller alike.
Games like Out of Ore →
Mitoza96% positive from 3,847 reviews202138% finish itDeck Playable
Surreal choice-driven exploration game. Players experience cycles of growth and decay, making decisions that impact the narrative.
What players likedPlayers praise Mitoza as a free, short, "choose your own adventure" game with an art style that offers many fun and unexpected possibilities.
The catchAmounts to picking A or B and watching animations, which gets repetitive fast.
Games like Mitoza →
This is a multi-ended visual novel where player choices shape relationships and determine one of four endings. It focuses on a high school student's second chance at social life and a unique romance.
What players likedPlayers praise this emotional and well-written visual novel as a step up from "Snoot Game," offering impactful choices and a memorable story.
The catchReviewers who liked it still refuse to recommend it over the developers' bigotry.
Games like I Wani Hug that Gator! →
This is a narrative puzzle game where players deduce a foreign language to build a relationship and shape a story. Its core loop involves interpreting words to understand and progress through a seven-day narrative.
What players likedPlayers praise its unique language puzzle mechanic, comparing it to games like Return of the Obra Dinn and Outer Wilds for its satisfying discovery.
The catchThere are no hints when progress stalls, so looking up a guide becomes the fix.
Games like 7 Days to End with You →
A short visual novel about a transgender woman's visit to hot springs, featuring branching dialogue and multiple endings.
What players likedPlayers praise this short, cute visual novel for its insightful and thoughtful representation of the transfem experience.
The catchBarely anything happens and the writing comes off preachy and shallow.
Games like one night, hot springs →
Narrative adventure game with dialogue choices and exploration. Features a Star Trek story with a focus on crew interaction and problem-solving.
What players likedPlayers praise it as a TNG-era Star Trek movie or episode, with an engaging story and meaningful choices.
The catchBugs, glitches and stutter run right through it and were never patched out.
Games like Star Trek: Resurgence →
This is a single-player comedy adventure RPG with turn-based combat and exploration. It features a prohibition-era setting with stick-figure characters and eldritch horrors.
What players likedPlayers praise its humorous writing, charming art, and challenging puzzles, comparing it favorably to West of Loathing and Kingdom of Loathing.
The catchA bloated step down from West of Loathing, with padded combat and obtuse puzzles.
Games like Shadows Over Loathing →
Five Dates85% positive from 2,813 reviews202024% finish itDeck Verified
This is a live-action FMV romantic comedy where player choices shape conversations and relationships with five potential dates. The game explores modern digital dating through branching dialogue and interactive scenarios.
What players likedPlayers praise its deep exploration of love and realistic portrayal of dating, akin to a light-hearted comedy FMV.
The catchThe five women come across as unlikable archetypes and the dialogue feels staged.
Games like Five Dates →
This is a rogue-like survival simulation game focused on character development and resource management. It offers an emotional, serious experience exploring themes of homelessness and resilience.
What players likedPlayers praise the realistic survival mechanics and rewarding progression, similar to other games where small achievements feel meaningful.
The catchBugs and crashes routinely wreck runs hours in, wiping progress and saves.
Games like CHANGE: A Homeless Survival Experience →
This is a kitchen management game with dialogue choices and multiple endings. Players serve customers while discussing the end of the world, offering a meditative psycho-horror experience.
What players likedPlayers praise its unique narrative and character backstories, often comparing it to a short, story-rich walking simulator with cooking elements.
The catchSold as a kitchen management sim but the cooking is a thin wrapper for cutscenes.
Games like While We Wait Here →
Narrative text RPG where players make choices to alter a predetermined destiny in a medieval world. The core loop involves reading journal entries and making decisions that shape the protagonist's skills and plot.
What players likedPlayers praise the impactful choices and branching narrative, reminiscent of classic choose-your-own-adventure games.
The catchStat and energy checks often block the choice your character would obviously make.
Games like The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante — Chapter 1&2 →
80 Days90% positive from 2,026 reviews201541% finish itDeck Verified
A narrative adventure game where players manage resources to race around a 3D globe, making choices to survive and succeed. It features a steampunk setting and a constant time pressure.
What players likedPlayers praise its open-ended adventure and steampunk world, offering many routes and discoveries like a choose-your-own-adventure travelogue.
The catchUnskippable intro credits play before the game starts
Games like 80 Days →
IMMORTALITY84% positive from 1,942 reviews202234% finish itDeck Verified
An interactive film trilogy where players match cut through footage to solve a mystery, featuring a cinematic teleportation mechanic and a dark, investigative feel.
What players likedPlayers praise its satisfying mystery-solving and discovery, comparing it to Sam Barlow's "Her Story" but with a focus on film reels.
The catchFinding clips means clicking objects at random, which becomes repetitive busywork.
Games like IMMORTALITY →
Interactive sci-fi novel where you design robots and make choices that shape their development and the world over thirty years. Your decisions determine robot sentience, their relationship with humanity, and your personal life.
What players likedPlayers praise its well-explained story that makes you feel in charge of a growing machine, akin to exploring the complexities of AI.
The catchThe story railroads everyone into a US China war plot no matter which choices you pick.
Games like Choice of Robots →
Disturbed92% positive from 1,864 reviews201627% finish it
Hand-drawn adventure horror visual novel about a struggling farmer facing despair. Players make choices to navigate a bleak narrative with a focus on emotional struggle.
What players likedPlayers praise its short, simple, and memorable gameplay, offering an amazing experience despite many deaths.
The catchChoices kill you with no warning or clues, reducing play to save and reload.
Games like Disturbed →
A hand-drawn narrative adventure where players manage distractions to meet a deadline. It features multiple endings and a free, extended story chapter.
What players likedPlayers praise its charming art, relatable procrastination, and anti-corporate/AI themes, comparing it to "13 Storey Treehouse" and "Lumber Lass."
The catchThere is no working fast forward, so replaying for other endings is a slog.
Games like Endless Monday: Dreams and Deadlines →
Whos Lila?95% positive from 1,797 reviews2022Deck Verified
This is a point-and-click adventure game where players control character facial expressions to drive dialogue. It features a surreal, dither-punk aesthetic and a mystery narrative.
What players likedPlayers praise its unique, convoluted mystery and face-making gameplay, often compared to multimedia mysteries and David Lynch.
The catchSeeing the full story means replaying the same scenes many times until it drags.
Games like Whos Lila? →
Narrative-driven open-world RPG with strategic caravan management and tactical turn-based combat in a dark fantasy wasteland. Explore, trade, and survive perilous journeys with your companions.
What players likedPlayers praise Vagrus as a deep, lore-rich caravan simulator and RPG, often compared to Sunless Sea, Kenshi, and Darksun.
The catchTravel and combat are slow and tedious, turning progress into a long grind.
Games like Vagrus - The Riven Realms →
This is an AI-powered escape room game where players use dialogue to solve puzzles and influence yandere NPCs. It features endless story possibilities and reactive AI for a suspenseful, psychological experience.
What players likedPlayers praise its unique AI-driven NPC interactions, making it feel like an immersive escape room or D&D experience.
The catchThe AI forgets what it said and invents objects and events the game does not have.
Games like AI2U: With You 'Til The End →
3D platformer where players use paint and thinner to alter environments and influence the story. It features classic Disney characters and reimagined levels with improved controls and movement.
What players likedPlayers praise this collectathon platformer with light immersive sim elements and moral choices for its beautiful art style and Disney history references.
The catchAreas and collectibles lock away permanently with no warning and no manual save.
Games like Disney Epic Mickey: Rebrushed →
Ib98% positive from 1,562 reviews201213% finish itDeck Verified
A 2D pixel art exploration adventure game where players solve puzzles and make choices to escape a mysterious art gallery. It features multiple endings and updated graphics.
What players likedPlayers praise "Ib" as a classic RPG Maker horror puzzle game with engaging storytelling, atmosphere, and improved art.
The catchToo short and too close to the still free original to justify the price.
Games like Ib →
This is an episodic narrative adventure game where players make choices that impact the story. It features a story-driven exploration and dialogue system with quick-time events.
The catchThe story and characters are dull, and it lands weaker than the first season.
Games like Minecraft: Story Mode - Season Two →
Psychological horror game with interactive cartoon elements and environmental exploration. Players interact with a character and explore to uncover a dark story.
What players likedPlayers praise its expanded lore and puzzles, building on the first game's analogue horror while offering a great, well-made experience.
The catchPuzzles regularly bug out or fail to trigger, blocking progress and forcing restarts.
Games like Amanda the Adventurer 2 →
ACE Academy95% positive from 1,470 reviews2016Deck Playable
This is a comedy-centric, slice-of-life visual novel with romance and sci-fi elements. Players make hundreds of choices to personalize their story and relationships.
What players likedPlayers praise ACE Academy as a polished, well-written visual novel with likable characters and natural relationship routes, even for newcomers.
The catchThe main story stops dead partway through with no ending or resolution.
Games like ACE Academy →
The Yawhg83% positive from 1,454 reviews2014Deck Verified
A 1-4 player choose-your-own-adventure with randomized stories and over 50 endings. It offers a dark, consequence-driven narrative about a town facing impending doom.
What players likedPlayers praise its unique atmosphere and writing, comparing it to a simple, short, and fun party game.
The catchEach run ends in ten to twenty minutes, with little content for the price.
Games like The Yawhg →
This is a text-based adventure game where players make choices for the protagonist, Kyle, to reach one of 117 unique endings. The core loop involves guiding Kyle through his day, preventing him from making disastrous decisions.
What players liked(No information provided to answer the question.)
The catchThe absurd humor wears thin fast and replaying the same branches becomes a grind.
Games like Kyle is Famous: Complete Edition →
Crystalline94% positive from 1,360 reviews2018Deck Unsupported
This is a comedy fantasy visual novel with a relationship simulator. Players make choices to shape their story and relationships with fully voiced, animated characters.
The catchDespite the choose-your-own-adventure billing, choices barely change the story.
Games like Crystalline →
