Games like The Blackwell Legacy

A point-and-click adventure game where a medium and a ghost solve supernatural mysteries.

90% positive from 1,635 · 2012 · 42% finish it · Steam Deck Verified · Lowest ever $0.49 (2014-06-24)

Point & ClickAdventureIndieFemale ProtagonistSupernaturalMystery

Six games like The Blackwell Legacy

97% positive from 830 reviews201475% finish itDeck Verified

Point-and-click adventure game with supernatural investigation. Players control a psychic and a ghost to solve mysteries.

What players likedPlayers praise the cohesive story, memorable characters, and immersive atmosphere, best experienced by playing the whole series.

The catchThe ending abandons the setup from earlier games and lands as contrived and unsatisfying.

Both are tagged Supernatural, Mystery and Point & Click.

Games like Blackwell Epiphany →

OXENFREE II: Lost Signals

88% positive from 2,057 reviews202345% finish itDeck Verified

Narrative adventure game with branching dialogue choices and a walkie-talkie mechanic. It's a supernatural mystery with a focus on player decisions.

What players likedPlayers praise its "Twin Peaks"-like atmosphere, engaging story, and improved mechanics, building on the original Oxenfree.

The catchRecycles the first game with flatter characters and far less of its mystery.

Both are tagged Supernatural, Mystery and Female Protagonist.

Games like OXENFREE II: Lost Signals →

Unavowed

95% positive from 1,862 reviews201835% finish itDeck Verified

This is a narrative-driven point-and-click adventure game with branching storylines and companion characters. Players experience a dark fantasy story of redemption and fighting evil.

What players likedPlayers praise Unavowed as a replayable adventure game with an excellent story, tough choices, and cohesive puzzles, unlike typical point-and-click or AAA titles.

The catchPuzzles are trivially easy, closer to a linear visual novel than an adventure game.

Both are tagged Supernatural, Point & Click and Adventure.

Games like Unavowed →

At Dead Of Night

94% positive from 3,469 reviews202020% finish itDeck Playable

This is a live-action horror game where you play as Maya, using a ghost receiver to uncover a psychopath's secret and save her friends. It blends film and gameplay for an immersive, spooky experience.

What players likedPlayers praise its unique live-action, point-and-click horror, comparing it to classic adventure and horror games.

The catchHiding from the same stalker in samey corridors gets repetitive within a few hours.

Both are tagged Supernatural, Point & Click and Indie.

Games like At Dead Of Night →

Necrobarista

82% positive from 1,456 reviews202019% finish itDeck Verified

This is a 3D visual novel about death and coffee, featuring cinematic presentation and free-roaming exploration. It focuses on character stories within a fantasy Melbourne setting.

What players likedPlayers praise Necrobarista as an awesome game with a powerful message, reminiscent of titles like The Talos Principle and Gris.

The catchStory and characters feel underwritten despite a strong premise

Both are tagged Supernatural, Female Protagonist and Indie.

Games like Necrobarista →

Dollmare

94% positive from 2,102 reviews202424% finish itDeck Playable

This is a psychological horror game where you inspect dolls for anomalies. It features a dynamic, unscripted experience focused on building dread and unease.

What players likedPlayers praise "Dollmare" as an addicting, replayable, and unique horror game akin to "Chucky's factory" with a tense, unsettling atmosphere.

The catchThe workday loop repeats the same doll checks with too little variety between days.

Both are tagged Supernatural, Adventure and Indie.

Games like Dollmare →

More like this: Female Protagonist Point & Click Mystery

More about The Blackwell Legacy

What players liked

Players praise its intriguing story, voice acting, and nostalgic art style, finding it an enjoyable point-and-click adventure that launched a beloved series.

The catch

It ends in about two hours and plays more like an intro chapter than a full game.

Reviews: 90% positive from 1,635
Released: 2012
Finish it: 42% of players
Steam Deck: Steam Deck Verified
Price: Lowest ever $0.49 (2014-06-24)
Play: Single-player

It is here because it sits in the band this site looks at: well reviewed at 90% positive, but with 1,635 reviews, far fewer than the household names carry.

View The Blackwell Legacy on Steam

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing

This page was built automatically from stored Steam data. How these pages are made.