SecludedGems Try it free

SecludedGems / Games like

Games like Scarlet Hollow

98% positive from 4,077 reviewsReleased 2025Steam Deck Verified$29.99
Scarlet Hollow on Steam

What it is

This is a branching narrative horror-mystery game with trait-based dialogue. Players investigate paranormal events and make impactful choices that shape the story and relationships.

The catch

Still unfinished after years, with episodes arriving rarely and running very short.

Why it is here

It is here because it sits in the band this site looks at: well reviewed at 98% positive, but with 4,077 reviews, far fewer than the household names carry.

View Scarlet Hollow on Steam

Six games like Scarlet Hollow

Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma
Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma
82% positive from 4,829 reviews

Nine people wake in an underground facility and are told the exit opens only after six of them die. Search 3D rooms for escape puzzles...

The catchA weak twist and unresolved plot threads make the trilogy's finale a letdown.

Both are tagged Choices Matter, Psychological Horror and Visual Novel.

The Test: Reality Check
The Test: Reality Check
96% positive from 645 reviews

This is a short, psychological horror simulation where players answer yes/no questions to reveal hidden truths about themselves. It...

Both are tagged Choices Matter, Psychological Horror and Visual Novel.

Little Misfortune
Little Misfortune
92% positive from 13,812 reviews

An interactive story game about exploration and choices. It features a dark, whimsical feel with a young protagonist seeking happiness.

Both are tagged Choices Matter, Psychological Horror and Story Rich.

Scarlet Hollow — Episode 1
Scarlet Hollow — Episode 1
96% positive from 707 reviews

This is a horror visual novel adventure game with a branching narrative and a complex relationship system. Your choices impact character...

Both are tagged Choices Matter, Visual Novel and Story Rich.

The Letter - Horror Visual Novel
The Letter - Horror Visual Novel
86% positive from 1,520 reviews

This is a horror visual novel with a branching narrative where player choices impact character relationships and story outcomes. It...

Both are tagged Choices Matter, Visual Novel and Story Rich.

While We Wait Here
While We Wait Here
89% positive from 2,350 reviews

This is a kitchen management game with dialogue choices and multiple endings. Players serve customers while discussing the end of the...

The catchSold as a kitchen management sim but the cooking is a thin wrapper for cutscenes.

Both are tagged Choices Matter, Psychological Horror and Horror.

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing

This page was built automatically from stored Steam data. How these pages are made.