Games like Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition

94% positive from 2,945 reviewsReleased 2009Steam Deck Playable$9.99

Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition on Steam

Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition screenshot

What it is

This is a first-person horror adventure game focused on puzzle-solving and environmental interaction. It features a dark, psychological atmosphere with a compelling story.

What players liked

Players praise its gripping story, dense atmosphere, and creative puzzles, noting its influence on games like Amnesia: The Bunker.

The catch

A wisecracking voice in your head talks constantly and deflates the horror atmosphere.

Why it is here

It is here because it sits in the band this site looks at: well reviewed at 94% positive, but with 2,945 reviews, far fewer than the household names carry.

View Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition on Steam

More like this: Stealth Horror Psychological Horror Atmospheric

Six games like Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition

Granny Remake

82% positive from 2,111 reviews20235% finish itDeck Playable

This is a survival horror game where players solve puzzles and use stealth to escape a house stalked by an adaptive AI enemy. The core loop involves exploration, item gathering, and evading Granny.

What players likedPlayers praise "Granny Remake" as an immersive and creepy revamp of the original, featuring new escapes, puzzles, and improved jumpscares.

The catchThe visuals improved but the gameplay, model and scares are worse than the original.

Both are tagged Stealth, Psychological Horror and Atmospheric.

Games like Granny Remake →

Thief Gold (1999)

92% positive from 4,131 reviews2012Deck Unsupported

First-person stealth game where players use shadows and tools to steal. It features a dark, deceptive world with challenging enemy AI.

What players likedPlayers praise its unparalleled dark fantasy atmosphere and unique blend of stealth and adventure, feeling weird and irreplaceable.

The catchThe later missions are confusing mazes where everything looks alike and you get lost.

Both are tagged Stealth, Atmospheric and First-Person.

Games like Thief Gold (1999) →

Thief: Deadly Shadows

81% positive from 2,583 reviews2007Deck Playable

Stealth action game where you play a master thief. Sneak, steal, and explore a responsive city with dynamic shadows.

What players likedPlayers praise its fantastic level design, writing, and horror elements, giving it a classic Thief vibe despite not matching earlier games.

The catchThe lockpicking minigame often breaks in the tutorial and blocks all further progress.

Both are tagged Stealth, Atmospheric and First-Person.

Games like Thief: Deadly Shadows →

Thief II: The Metal Age

94% positive from 2,108 reviews2012Deck Unsupported

Stealth FPS with non-linear levels. Outsmart guards using tools and AI.

What players likedPlayers praise Thief II as one of the greatest immersive sims, expanding on its predecessor, The Dark Project.

The catchThe Steam release needs unofficial fan patches to fix low resolution and crashes.

Both are tagged Stealth, Atmospheric and First-Person.

Games like Thief II: The Metal Age →

KARMA: The Dark World

92% positive from 4,412 reviews202550% finish itDeck Verified

This is a first-person psychological thriller where players investigate memories using advanced tech. It features a dystopian 1984 East Germany setting with a focus on espionage and betrayal.

What players likedPlayers praise its deep, emotional, and thought-provoking psychological horror story, often compared to "1984," "Still Wakes The Deep," and "Observer: System Redux."

The catchThe story starts strong then collapses into a confusing ending that explains nothing.

Both are tagged Psychological Horror, Atmospheric and First-Person.

Games like KARMA: The Dark World →

Fears to Fathom - Woodbury Getaway

87% positive from 3,448 reviews202460% finish itDeck Playable

Psychological horror walking simulator with VHS aesthetic. Explore, drive, fish, and make choices to survive a weekend getaway.

What players likedPlayers praise its immersive, cozy, and realistic horror, feeling like a vivid dream or a quality step above similar short horrors.

The catchWeak suspense and scares compared to earlier episodes

Both are tagged Psychological Horror, Atmospheric and First-Person.

Games like Fears to Fathom - Woodbury Getaway →

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing

This page was built automatically from stored Steam data. How these pages are made.