Games like Magical Diary: Horse Hall

90% positive from 1,018 reviewsReleased 201215% finish it

What it is

A magical school simulation game where players learn spells, make friends, and navigate social and academic challenges. Decisions shape relationships and unlock branching storylines with multiple endings.

What players liked

Players praise its enjoyable gameplay and hope for more content beyond the current freshman year.

The catch

You collect dozens of spells but only need a few basic ones to pass everything.

Why it is here

It is here because it sits in the band this site looks at: well reviewed at 90% positive, but with 1,018 reviews, far fewer than the household names carry.

View Magical Diary: Horse Hall on Steam

More like this: Anime Female Protagonist Visual Novel Dating Sim

Six games like Magical Diary: Horse Hall

目盲/Blind

85% positive from 897 reviews202227% finish it

This is a narrative-driven adventure game where players make choices to uncover mysteries. It features a protagonist with face blindness who must balance ordinary life with supernatural events.

Both are tagged Dating Sim, Female Protagonist and Visual Novel.

Games like 目盲/Blind →

Amnesia™: Memories

92% positive from 4,300 reviews20157% finish itDeck Unsupported

This is a visual novel with branching romance paths and relationship management. Players navigate a memory loss narrative through dialogue choices and mini-games.

What players likedPlayers praise the deep story, multiple endings based on choices, and fully voiced characters, with Orion being compared to Paimon.

The catchThe fairy sidekick narrates for the heroine and is relentlessly annoying.

Both are tagged Dating Sim, Female Protagonist and Visual Novel.

Games like Amnesia™: Memories →

TAISHO x ALICE episode 1

86% positive from 1,354 reviews201917% finish itDeck Unsupported

A visual novel where players make choices to romance fairytale characters. It features a gender-swapped cast and multiple endings.

What players likedPlayers praise its interesting plot twists and character parallels, with good execution of its fairytale concept.

The catchThe heroine reads as obnoxious and unrelatable, which sinks both routes.

Both are tagged Dating Sim, Female Protagonist and Visual Novel.

Games like TAISHO x ALICE episode 1 →

BLUE REFLECTION: Second Light

82% positive from 1,099 reviews20214% finish itDeck Playable

This is a Japanese role-playing game featuring school life simulation and turn-based combat. Players develop a school and explore a mysterious world with magical girls.

The catchRepetitive dates and filler dialogue drag the story out into a chore.

Both are tagged Dating Sim, Female Protagonist and Visual Novel.

Games like BLUE REFLECTION: Second Light →

Love Curse: Find Your Soulmate

98% positive from 1,084 reviews202511% finish itDeck Playable

This is a visual novel with a dating sim element where the player must find their soulmate to avoid death. It features romance, mystery, and potentially dark themes.

What players likedPlayers praise "Love Curse" as one of the best, most emotional, and well-written yuri visual novels, offering complex characters and satisfying content.

The catchThe writing is bland and the supernatural curse plot is barely explained or explored.

Both are tagged Dating Sim, Female Protagonist and Visual Novel.

Games like Love Curse: Find Your Soulmate →

Fatal Twelve

92% positive from 1,020 reviews201822% finish itDeck Playable

A visual novel where players gather information to eliminate opponents in a death-defying ritual. It's a dark, character-driven narrative focused on uncovering truths and facing regrets.

What players likedPlayers praise this "death game" visual novel as a deeply emotional and engaging mystery, akin to others in the genre.

The catchThe death game builds no tension because secrets are handed over instead of deduced.

Both are tagged Dating Sim, Female Protagonist and Visual Novel.

Games like Fatal Twelve →

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing

This page was built automatically from stored Steam data. How these pages are made.