Games like Little Goody Two Shoes

95% positive from 1,588 reviewsReleased 20236% finish itSteam Deck Verified$19.99

What it is

Horror narrative adventure game with life management and branching endings. Players balance village life and survival in a fairy tale world.

What players liked

Players praise its gorgeous 90s anime art, rich storytelling, and haunting atmosphere, often comparing it to twisted fairy tales and RPG Maker horror games.

The catch

Minigames feel unfair and inconsistent

Why it is here

It is here because it sits in the band this site looks at: well reviewed at 95% positive, but with 1,588 reviews, far fewer than the household names carry.

View Little Goody Two Shoes on Steam

More like this: LGBTQ+ Horror Exploration Dating Sim

Six games like Little Goody Two Shoes

Chair F*cking Simulator

95% positive from 773 reviews20206% finish it

This is a surreal simulation game where players engage in "chair intercourse" through a unique dating and interaction mechanic. It offers a bizarre and challenging experience focused on pelvic thrust control and exploring chair lore.

Both are tagged LGBTQ+, Dating Sim and Horror.

Games like Chair F*cking Simulator →

Boyfriend Dungeon

92% positive from 2,658 reviews202143% finish itDeck Verified

Dating sim and dungeon crawler where you romance weapons that transform into people. Fight monsters, build relationships, and solve a mystery.

What players likedPlayers compare it to Hades and visual novels, praising its diverse characters and satisfying blend of roguelike combat and heartfelt interactions.

The catchNeither half lands, with button mashing combat and thin, predictable dating writing.

Both are tagged LGBTQ+, Dating Sim and RPG.

Games like Boyfriend Dungeon →

Monster Prom 2: Monster Camp

97% positive from 4,385 reviews20200% finish itDeck Verified

Multiplayer dating sim with a summer camp theme. Players choose dialogue options to romance monsters, with campfire mechanics and magic drinks.

What players likedPlayers praise "Monster Camp" as a fun and improved iteration of the first game, offering expanded storylines and enhanced gameplay mechanics.

The catchVague opening answers lock you into one date, ignoring who you actually wanted.

Both are tagged LGBTQ+ and Dating Sim.

Games like Monster Prom 2: Monster Camp →

Monster Prom 3: Monster Roadtrip

98% positive from 2,461 reviews20222% finish itDeck Verified

This is a co-op narrative adventure with survival mechanics where players manage resources on a road trip. It features charming characters and irreverent humor with a social competitive aspect.

What players likedPlayers praise its humor and unique narrative, comparing it favorably to previous Monster Prom entries for its approachable gameplay.

The catchIt plays as a random resource manager rather than the dating sim of earlier entries.

Both are tagged LGBTQ+ and Dating Sim.

Games like Monster Prom 3: Monster Roadtrip →

Monster Prom 4: Monster Con

98% positive from 1,879 reviews2025Deck Verified

Monster Prom 4: Monster Con is a multiplayer dating sim where players build a comic book while pursuing one of six monsters at a convention. It offers witty dialogue and charming characters in a humorous, nerdy setting.

What players likedPlayers praise this visual novel for its fun, humorous dating of hot monsters, unique art, multiplayer, and numerous endings.

The catchWriting and characters lack the charm and humour of the earlier games.

Both are tagged LGBTQ+ and Dating Sim.

Games like Monster Prom 4: Monster Con →

Kitty Powers' Matchmaker

96% positive from 1,770 reviews2015Deck Playable

A dating simulator where players manage a matchmaking agency, guiding clients through dates. It features procedural generation and agency upgrades with a humorous tone.

What players likedPlayers praise this unique and relaxing dating agency simulator for its fun minigames, lack of wait times, and addictive collecting.

The catchThe same few date minigames repeat every match and turn boring within an hour or two.

Both are tagged LGBTQ+ and Dating Sim.

Games like Kitty Powers' Matchmaker →

Or skip the lists entirely.

Describe what you feel like playing

This page was built automatically from stored Steam data. How these pages are made.